Which is the best Mattress Topper? Toppers vs Protectors vs Pads

With so many brands of mattress toppers available online, it's hard to know where to start when looking to buy a new mattress topper, or replace your old one. 

In order to save you a lot of time, we've done most of the hard work for you. Our Best Mattress Toppers List is based on our research and buyer reviews.

In this article we review the best 5 mattress toppers currently available. These may not be the best sellers on Amazon. If you dig a little deeper into Amazon reviews, you'll quickly see that their Best Selling mattress topper isn't necessarily the best quality, or best deal. 


What exactly is a Mattress Topper?

Mattress toppers are designed to fit on top of an existing bed mattress. Buying a mattress topper can significantly delay having to buy a brand new mattress. They extend the life of the mattress, and offer a great deal of extra comfort at the same time.

Not all mattress toppers are equal. These can range from various depths of the memory foam, to fiber fillings, gel, latex and more. Some are waterproof but many are not. Most of the toppers on our list are made of memory foam. Memory Foam mattress toppers mold to the shape of your body giving you a very comfortable night's sleep.

What's the difference between Mattress Toppers, Mattress Pads and Mattress Protectors?

Let's get this out of the way first as there's some confusion with the differences between mattress toppers, mattress pads and mattress protectors.

Some mattress toppers are waterproof, but most are not. They are designed to add additional comfort to a mattress.

Unlike mattress toppers which are used to provide more comfort, the main purpose of pads and protectors, is to protect the mattress from stains, normal wear and tear, dust mites and bed bugs. These are cheaper to clean or replace than replacing or cleaning your bed mattress.

There are stand-alone mattress protectors and pads available that are suitable for younger children who may wet the bed, or for people suffering from incontinence or nocturnal enuresis. People also buy pads and protectors simply to protect their beds and mattresses. 

Mattress Pad

Mattress Pad

Mattress Protector

Mattress Protector

Mattress Topper

Mattress Topper

Why is memory foam popular for Mattress Toppers?

Memory foam mattresses are hugely popular because of the comfort they provide. Considering that we spend on average around a third of our lives in bed, we may as well be as comfortable as possible. After all, no-one wants to wake up with a sore back or sore neck.

Mattress toppers made of memory foam are a temperature sensitive material. These mold to the shape of each individual person's body. They gently support shoulder and hip joints during the night to take the pressure off that cause these to become sore or painful. Many people find they drift off to sleep much faster on memory foam toppers as they're simply more comfortable than just a regular mattress.

What sizes do Mattress Toppers come in?

These can be bought in different bed sizes to suit the size of your bed, be it a twin, full, Queen, King or Californian King. You'll find that you'll pay slightly more for a larger sized mattress topper - which does makes sense. A  full size topper will be more expensive than a twin topper of the same type. 

Under the table, I have reviewed each of these in more detail, with images and more information.

Our list of the best Mattress Toppers for 2018

I could gather research and write reviews on the Best Sellers on Amazon, but being a Best Seller on Amazon doesn't always mean it is a quality product. Quite often you have to dig a little deeper to see how good (or bad) some of these Best Sellers really are. 

My list below are the best quality mattress toppers. These have been selected after spending many hours reading through all reviews and comments by real buyers who have bought the product, used it and then taken the time to leave a review. 

# 1 - Advanced Sleep Solutions 2" Gel Memory Foam Mattress Topper

The Advanced Sleep Solutions 2" Gel Memory Foam Mattress Topper comes with a 3 year warranty. The combination of gel and memory foam provides superb ventilation. Gel helps with the air flow and the topper doesn't retain your body heat, making this especially good to use during the warmer months of the year. These toppers are 100% made in the USA using eco-friendly materials.

The Advanced Sleep Solutions memory foam gel topper ships in a box. These come with a 60 Day Money Back Comfortably Perfect Guarantee and a 3 Year Manufacturers Warranty.

The blend of memory foam gel gives just the right amount of support. It relieves pressure points and supports your muscles, joints and spine alignment. Even if your partner is a restless sleeper, this memory foam support design absorbs their movements, making for a restful night's sleep.  

CertiPUR-US Certified Product
Advanced Sleep Solutions Gel Memory Foam Mattress Topper
Advanced Sleep Solutions Gel Memory Foam Mattress Toppers
5 S​tars
4 Stars
3 Stars
2 Stars
1 Star

# 2 - Memory Foam Solutions 2" Gel Swirl Visco Elastic Memory Foam Mattress Topper

Instantly makes any mattress cooler, more restful, comfortable, and supportive in sagging areas of mattress
2 inches of extra cooling gel swirl memory foam conforms to your body perfectly
Made in the USA. Exceeds PURGreen Certification standards
Cooling gel swirl memory foam reduces pressure points that cause you to toss and turn, so you sleep better
Topper features a cooling gel swirl memory foam and featuring a famous gel-like feel

Twin, Twin X, Full, Queen, King, Californian King

# 3 - Sleep Innovations 4" Plush Support Gel Memory Foam Mattress Topper

FULL MATTRESS TOPPER: Drift into a sounder, deeper sleep on this 4-inch full gel memory foam mattress cover ideal for side, back or stomach sleepers.
DUAL LAYER: A pillowy 1-inch layer of fiberfill adds extra cloud-like comfort in a reversible design that’s contoured to cradle the body. Snug-fit cover is removable and washer-and-dryer safe.
GEL MEMORY FOAM: Every body is unique and deserves personalized comfort— 3 inches of cooling gel memory foam draws heat away from the body to create the optimal sleep temperature.
COMFORT & SUPPORT: The full mattress topper combines 3 inches of gel memory foam with 1 inch of fiberfill for unbeatable comfort combined with gentle, pressure-relieving support that feels like floating on a cloud.
MADE IN THE USA: This Sleep Innovations mattress topper is proudly made in the USA, vacuum packed for easy shipping and handling and comes with a 10-year limited warranty.
The cooling support of gel memory foam to relieve pressure points, topped with a pillow-y layer of fiber-fill, for more comfortable sleep
Three inches of gel memory foam, one inch of fiber-fill, in a contoured, reversible design
Quilted, snug-fit cover is washer and dryer safe
For side, back, or stomach sleepers
Always holds its shape
10-year limited warranty
Foam made in USA

Twin, Full, Queen, King, Californian King

Red Nomad Ultra Premium Memory Foam Mattress Topper

No 4 Mattress Topper - Luxury Double Bed Orthopaedic Anti Allergy Mattress Topper

This mattress topper is from the Sweet Dream's company. This is one of the cheaper offers available and can be found from as little as £20.50. Although not quite as highly rated as the first three on our list, nonetheless, it still rates highly at 4.4 out of 5 stars.

The manufacturer describes this one as an anti-allergy luxury mattress topper. It is made from 100% Polyester and filled with micro fibre. It can be machine washed but only up to 30 degrees. Buyers seem to get this one for their children's room or for a guest bedroom, rather than for their main bed.

No 5 Mattress Topper - EXTRA DEEP 5" (12.5 cm) LUXURY Duck Feather and 15% Down Mattress Topper

This mattress topper is from the Viceroy Bedding company. This is the first of the luxury duck feather and down filled mattress toppers. You will always pay more for these as the filling is simply higher quality, but more expensive as a result.

This one also has a rating of 4.4 out of 5 stars. It costs on average around £43. 

It is boxed stitched to prevent the filling dropping to one end of the topper. The filling is 85% duck feather and 15% down.  This one is a deep topper at 5" / 12.5cm. The cover is made from 100% pure cotton cover, and that prevent feathers from sticking out.

It has been treated with ULTRAFRESH which inhibits dust mites and other common bacteria. There are elastic fasteners to go over your mattress so the topper stays in place.

Leave a Reply 0 comments

Leave a Reply: